Page 1 of 37" Plasma, 36"CRT or 32" LCD under £2000 television required!!!

Hardware Forum

37" Plasma, 36"CRT or 32" LCD under £2000 television required!!!

GCXBoy (Competent) posted this on Saturday, 16th April 2005, 14:13

I am going to buy a new television shortly and I am undecided which one to choose. I watch a lot of DVD movies, so I want a tele that gives the best quality picture with this source. The following qualities are required:

1. A Brand with a good reliability record.
2. Must have Component Input.
3. HDMI & PC input is not essential but will be an advantage.
4. A matching stand is required as I will not be hanging the tele on the wall.
5. The package must be stylish to Justify the price & impress family/friends.
6. Must have freeview built in.
7. Must be under £2000..

I would like to hear from those who have recently purchased plasma, LCD & CRT teles. I may discount CRTs because of flickering on progressive scan plus the sheer bulk/weight.

What are the pros & cons of each type? :/

This item was edited on Saturday, 16th April 2005, 15:25

RE: 37

gpen (Competent) posted this on Sunday, 17th April 2005, 06:55

The Hitachi 42" PD5200 scrapes in under that price if you buy on line - comes with a table-top stand and speakers, but no freeview, although might be worth considering buying a freeview box if you dont have sky/cable.

You can see the difference side-by side with the smaller 36/37" in the same range.

Update - bought mine here www.flatdeal.com/42pd5200.htm?dealtime - no problems, and now likes like they`re giving away a free 17" LCD.

This item was edited on Sunday, 17th April 2005, 08:00

RE: 37

USA Yankee (Competent) posted this on Sunday, 17th April 2005, 07:35

Most companies offer only 1yr manufactures warranty and then sell you extended warranties.
John Lewis stores not only price mtch high street prices but also give a 5yr warranty as standard, and you deal with them and not a third party.
When I have done comparisons in the past (internet & high strret) John Lewis always is the best buy.
A guy at work his Sony television went wrong 2 weeks before his 5yr warranty expired with John Lewis. John Lewis collect the television, 2 days later replaced it with a new television.
That`s what I call service which is rare these days in the UK.

RE: 37

kickback123 (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 17th April 2005, 11:03

carefull on that one mate.

the john lewis down my way seems to be changing there repairs policys and warranty periods so check on that one.

RE: 37" Plasma, 36"CRT or 32" LCD under £2000 television required!!!

Mikeonfreeserve (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 17th April 2005, 21:57

Ever watched sport on a plasma or LCD?

ha ha ha!

Give me a break.

Wait until the technology is sorted my friend.

You still cannot get better than a crt for picture quality.

No arguments.

RE: 37

Brooktop (Competent) posted this on Monday, 18th April 2005, 08:07

Quote:
Ever watched sport on a plasma or LCD?

ha ha ha!


You`ve not been watching the right ones! Or looking in Comet???

Absolute tosh! Get a decent one that`s set up right and you`ll be amazed. Plus if you`ve got a load of mates round, you`re not all huddled round a poxy size screen.

You`ll get a 37" Panasonic Viera plasma for under £2k. My g/f`s dad has one and all he watches is sport and movies. It will meet all your requirements bar HDMI...and that`s not really something to worry about for the average joe yet for a few years...

This item was edited on Monday, 18th April 2005, 09:12

RE: 37

gpen (Competent) posted this on Monday, 18th April 2005, 17:36

Sport can look a bit off, but it is usually the fault of the broadcaster - try a non-Premiership/Championship game on Sky, where the production facilities are limited.

Basically, a plasma/LCD is more likely to show up any shortcomings in the original signal due to the higher resolutions that they are capable of displaying - they don`t improve a poor original signal.

As for HDMI, a number of plasmas now come with a DVI connector which apparently will be suitable for Sky`s hi-def service if it has HDCP capability.

RE: 37

Mikeonfreeserve (Elite) posted this on Monday, 18th April 2005, 20:13

£2000 for a smeary pic in motion?

No thanks.

Get a bonkers good crt for a third of that and a projector if you want proper big for movies.

You know it makes sense.

RE: 37

Brooktop (Competent) posted this on Tuesday, 19th April 2005, 08:54

Quote:
Get a bonkers good crt for a third of that and a projector if you want proper big for movies.


What about the cost of the extension? :o

Seriouly though, OP - go see some demos and make your own mind up. I went from a 32" Sony Wega (a stonking good CRT I think you`ll agree) to a 42" Panasonic plasma (now about £1100) and I`m well impressed. I`m not a big sport watcher, but when I do, there`s nothing wrong with it at all!! No smearing at all! Although I have seen that effect on inferior plasmas and I admit it is annoying.

Also, if you do go for a 36" CRT - the Panasonic (Tau range I think) and Toshiba (picture frame 3 series) are regarded as the best - but they are also known to have problems with motion blur because the technology is at its limits at 36". Also make sure you have 3 people to lift it!! I was in the same position as you a few months ago. I opted for plasma and the three sets I considered are: Panasonic PWD6 (NB screen only - cos I already have an AV set up), LG 42PX11 TV and Hitachi 42PD5200. All will be well within your budget. The latter two have DVI but only the Hitachi has 1024 x 768 resolution.

Go to AV Forums website and gen up!

This item was edited on Tuesday, 19th April 2005, 10:13

RE: 37

Bowf (Elite) posted this on Tuesday, 19th April 2005, 11:20

Sony have a multi-award winning 32" LCD with HDTV connections for £1500.00.
The hell with Plasma.

Here it is

http://www.unbeatable.co.uk/CatalogueItem_19782.html

Once you`re in the link,scroll down and you`ll see all the awards it`s won.

This item was edited on Tuesday, 19th April 2005, 12:22

Go back to Hardware Forum threads, or All Forum threads