About This Item

Preview Image for Stories From Trumpton (UK)
Stories From Trumpton (UK) (DVD Details)

Unique ID Code: 0000031354
Added by: Mark Oates
Added on: 10/3/2002 23:00
View Changes

Other Reviews, etc
  • Log in to Add Reviews, Videos, Etc
  • Places to Buy

    Searching for products...

    Review of Stories From Trumpton

    4 / 10

    Introduction


    This disk is a wallow in nostalgia for those of us who were rugrats in the late 1960`s. Trumpton, Camberwick Green and Chigley were cornerstones of BBC Childrens` programming throughout the 1970`s, and hark back to a gentle era when a "shout" for Trumpton Fire Brigade was more likely to involve rescuing a cat than extinguishing a torched Sierra on the council estate. This is the world of Pugh, Pugh, Barney McGrew, Cuthbert, Dibble and Grubb, of gentle songs about window cleaners and printers and the avuncular narration of the great Brian Cant.



    Video


    It is unfortunate that this series has not survived the passage of time as well as more mature series of the same vintage. The master quality of the eight episodes on this disk can be best described as appalling in the spent-eighteen-years-stored-under-somebody`s-bed sense. The prints show terrible wear and tear, with a great deal of scratches and dirt visible. The image is grainy and distinctly soft-focussed, but that may be inherent from the original time of production. Most worrying is the print weave and crawl obvious on some of the episodes, manifested as a wobbling of the image as if projected on a sheet flapping in the breeze.



    Audio


    As with the video, no attempt has been made to improve the sound quality of the disk. Sound is in glorious Mono, but anything tricky would detract from the whole "Watch With Mother" experience.



    Features


    Absolutely nothing. Not even subtitles. There is an animated menu but that only gives episode access. There are no chapter stops, only separate titles on the disk, so you might as well holster your remote while playing this one.



    Conclusion


    The adventures of Trumpton Fire Brigade, the Mayor, Miss Lovelace, Mrs Cobbit and Chippy Minton might be a little genteel for today`s Tweenie-worshippers, but the strength of this disk is as a nostalgia item. It is a pity Telstar have not made an effort to produce a better disk. The quality of this disk borders on the unacceptable, but that is largely due to the condition of the source material. It is a shame that so much material aimed at children has been handled with such a cavalier attitude over the years. Other programmes have survived the vagaries of storage - witness The Avengers, Dad`s Army or the original Randall and Hopkirk - but so much "Childrens`" Television is either lost, in terrible condition or simply will never been seen again.

    Your Opinions and Comments

    Carumba! Who'd a thought that this review would itself be resurrected 10 years later and be a form of nostalgia in its own right! ;)
    posted by Stuart McLean on 15/3/2012 22:21
    The awful thing about this release was it was mastered from a really dodgy 16mm print with worn sprockets.  The transfer house that did the job did the best they could with the material at hand, but they really needed better to start with.  I found out from the redoubtable Steve Roberts of the Dr Who Restoration team that such wobbling or "rubberbanding" was a scanning artefact caused by the slackness of the worn sprocket holes against the scanner's synchronisation sprocket (or words to that effect) - suffice to say when sprocket met sprocket hole a millisecond early, it mucked up the height of the completed frame and caused the bouncing effect.

    You learn something every day in this game...
    posted by Mark Oates on 16/3/2012 04:20
    Have they ever been able to better this on subsequent releases or is this as good (or bad) as it got?
    posted by Stuart McLean on 16/3/2012 08:11
    Oh, later editions have been a huge improvement.  Last year BBC Studios and Post Production did a full restoration
    posted by Mark Oates on 16/3/2012 15:27