Page 1 of Progressive scan - do I need it?

Hardware Forum

Progressive scan - do I need it?

AdamR (Competent) posted this on Monday, 23rd August 2004, 21:38

I don`t own a plasma or LCD TV and have no plans to purchase one in the near future. Is there any benefit at all to me having a DVD player capable of progressive scan output?

I wouldn`t avoid a player that had this capability, but I just wondered if there was any reason to look for progressive scan output.

RE: Progressive scan - do I need it?

Westy (Elite) posted this on Tuesday, 24th August 2004, 12:53

If you don`t have a progressive scan tv, then no is the simple answer.

NTSC signals on a 28" to 32" tv still look great anyhow, so even then progressive scan is more of a luxury than any real benefit. Move up the sizes to 36" CRT/LCD/Plasma and then you`ll start to see the difference :)

Obviously this is just my opinion and others here may say different, but in my experience of progressive scan i`ve found the above applies to my eyes



Westy
ytseW[at]reweiveR/supermanflyingskybkgrnd.gif">ytseW[at]reweiveR/supermanflyingskybkgrnd.gif" class="forumImage" />
After the foot incident, Westy had taken the speedy recovery a bit too seriously....

Site Technical Help Editor and Moderator -- Got a Question? Enter the mind of Westy

Click Here to Read the Latest Ask Westy Column

RE: Progressive scan - do I need it?

Cerbera (Mostly Harmless) posted this on Tuesday, 24th August 2004, 21:05

On the subject of Progressive Scan, does anyone know if the Panasonic PT-AE200 Projector is capable of processing a Progressive Scan signal? Nowt in the manual to say either way!

RE: Progressive scan - do I need it?

Westy (Elite) posted this on Wednesday, 25th August 2004, 17:37

Most certainly mate, the PAET100 does it so i`d imagine the 200 does it too



Westy
ytseW[at]reweiveR/supermanflyingskybkgrnd.gif">ytseW[at]reweiveR/supermanflyingskybkgrnd.gif" class="forumImage" />
After the foot incident, Westy had taken the speedy recovery a bit too seriously....

Site Technical Help Editor and Moderator -- Got a Question? Enter the mind of Westy

Click Here to Read the Latest Ask Westy Column

RE: Progressive scan - do I need it?

Cerbera (Mostly Harmless) posted this on Wednesday, 25th August 2004, 19:05

Quality! In your trusted opinion Westy, what would you consider a worthy upgrade for my good ole Pioneer 717? Needless to say it cost me an arm and a leg at the time (compared to today`s prices) and still had to pay more to have it upgraded to multi-region. Can`t complain though cos I have to admit it has been a brilliant player producing outstanding quality audio and video.

Now that I`ve finally moved to a large screen image via the Panny AE-200 Projector, I guess it`s time to consider YET ANOTHER home cinema upgrade. Component Video output and Progressive Scan being the main requirements (DTS compatibility too but that`s standard on all players these days). Obviously HAS to be multi-region, able to handle most disc formats (the 717 is fussy with DVD-R`s) and I guess it would be nice to have SACD / DVD-Audio but not essential as I haven`t tested these sources yet.

I`ve used Pioneer players since my old LaserDisc days so I trust their brand and quality. The slimline 575 and bigger brother 757 look tasty but what would you recommend matey? I don`t mind paying a bit extra for quality without going too nuts if you know what I mean!

Go back to Hardware Forum threads, or All Forum threads