Page 1 of Hidden tracks on CDs

Music Forum

Hidden tracks on CDs

David Beckett (Reviewer) posted this on Saturday, 5th February 2005, 13:34

Why? Irritating bloody things that serve no purpose at all.

________________________________________________________________

"Never trust a man who, when left alone in a room with a tea cosy, doesn`t try it on."
Billy Connolly

My Top 20 Horror Movies ---- My DVD Collection

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

admars (Elite) posted this on Saturday, 5th February 2005, 17:10

My opinion is is that it`s like DVD Easter Eggs, i.e. a cunning ploy to make you think you`re getting something extra for free.

Especially annoying are the ones where the last track is say 25mins long, the first 5 mins of which is a song, then 15mins of silence, then another 5 minute song. I used to hate that cos my 1 st CD player you could ony ffwd song to song, not in a song :(

If I was an artist i`d want ppl to hear all the songs I had recorded!!!

I remember a mate had an REM CD ( I forget which one, I`m not even 100% sure it was REM) where if you "rewound" a certain track, the time would come up as - mins, so you`d get an extra song. Obviosuly we were impressed at the time, but then we only ever heard that song if some-one was about who had not witnessed this "cool" hidden bonus.

Alan

www.admars.co.uk

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

cassius76 (Elite) posted this on Saturday, 5th February 2005, 17:58

both of the UNKLE albums have hidden tracks. you have to "rewind" the first track to get to track 0

My DVD collection





Gamertag Database

What I`m listening to

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

jeffthegun (Elite) posted this on Saturday, 5th February 2005, 19:10

The one at the end of Nevermind used to scare the crap out of me EVERY time i listened to the damn album. 15 minutes of silence followed by loud shouting.

One of my faves is the Bass tester one at the end of Leftism. Thats some bowel loosening bass.



I Dont know Karate...but I know Ker-azy!
What im listening to (if youre interested)

This item was edited on Saturday, 5th February 2005, 19:11

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

bigfan (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 02:12

Two of my favourites:

Blue Flashing Light, the track at the end of Travis` The Man Who

Smoking the Herb Again (purely for cheese value) from Incubus` "Incubus Attacks"


What I`m listening to...

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

David Beckett (Reviewer) posted this on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 12:01

Why do they make you wait 10-25 minutes to listen to the track though? Why don`t they just add the track as an extra track on the album and not have a load of dead air in which most people will take the CD out thinking it has finished?

________________________________________________________________

"Never trust a man who, when left alone in a room with a tea cosy, doesn`t try it on."
Billy Connolly

My Top 20 Horror Movies ---- My DVD Collection

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

jeffthegun (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 12:10

doesnt really bother me. otherwise it would sort of defy the point of it being a hidden track...

youve got too much time on your hands.



I Dont know Karate...but I know Ker-azy!
What im listening to (if youre interested)

This item was edited on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 12:11

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

bigfan (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 13:28

The two I mentioned are only 30 seconds or so after the last track, I think.

I reckon the main reason they do it for 25 minutes is to push the disc to the limits - it`s a form of copy protection, as factory pressed CDs have a higher capacity than standard 74 / 80 minute discs. This means that the average person will try to copy it and be told there isn`t enough room.

Obviously you can get round this by copying individual tracks, but most novice users can`t be arsed / don`t know how to.


What I`m listening to...

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

skeletonkey (Elite) posted this on Sunday, 6th February 2005, 21:00

I also find them annoying.

Worst one was at the end of Monaco`s album (remember them? :/ ) when someone says "You can turn it off now" after about 10 minutes silence!

Usually the tracks aren`t very good and so didn`t make it on to the final album. I can`t think of any really good hidden tracks. Maybe Time Travel at the end of The Coral`s debut album, but mostly they are a waste of time!

RE: Hidden tracks on CDs

"V" (Elite) posted this on Saturday, 12th February 2005, 00:59

Always good to put on in the local pub though - has the loudys heaping coins into the juke box thinking there`s dead air to be filled

Live a life you love, use a god you trust, and don`t take it all too seriously

Go back to Music Forum threads, or All Forum threads